Founders often conflate business coaches and startup advisors — but they offer completely different things. Here's how to know what you actually need at each stage.
A startup advisor is typically a domain expert — someone who has built companies or operated in your specific industry — who offers strategic guidance, introductions, and perspective. They share what they know. A business coach focuses on your development as a founder and leader — they help you think more clearly, make better decisions, and build the skills you need. Advisors give you answers; coaches help you find them.
A business coach is most valuable when the challenge is about how you operate as a founder: your decision-making, your leadership of the team, your ability to think strategically, or the habits and beliefs that are limiting your growth. If you keep facing the same problems in different forms, or you know what needs to happen but can't execute consistently — that's a coaching problem.
An advisor is most valuable when you need specific domain knowledge or connections you don't have: industry expertise, technical know-how, investor relationships, or experience with a specific growth challenge at a specific scale. Advisors are most useful when you know what you're trying to do and need someone who has done it to guide the specific execution.
Some mentors and advisors naturally adopt a coaching stance — asking powerful questions rather than just giving advice. But be deliberate about which mode you need at any given time. The danger is an advisor who gives you their answers when you need to develop your own capacity to find the right answers for your context.
Advisors are typically compensated with equity — 0.1% to 0.5% is common for genuine advisory relationships, often with a 1-year vesting schedule. Business coaches are paid in cash for their time. Be cautious of 'advisors' who want equity in exchange for vague promises of introductions — the best advisors are motivated by a genuine interest in the company, not the equity.
Look for coaches with direct experience building or scaling companies — not just coaching theory. Ask specifically about their experience with companies at your stage and in your sector. Check whether they focus on founder development (coaching) or strategy (consulting), and be clear which you need. A discovery call is essential before committing.
◈ FEATURED COACHES
Explore coaches specialising in this area: Dan Sullivan, Michael E. Gerber, Eben Pagan, Gary Vaynerchuk, Marie Forleo, Dean Graziosi
◈ Find Your Coach
Browse our directory of verified coaches across every specialty.
Browse Coaches →